Standard News

Hide Advertisement
  • Business
  • Culture
  • News
  • Technology
  • Trending
Site logo
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
News

U.S. top court deals blow to Puerto Rico sovereignty claim

By Reuters 2 min read
  • # Updated
Cars move in the afternoon traffic on the expressway Las Americas in San Juan

By Lawrence Hurley

(Reuters) – The U.S. Supreme Court on Thursday ruled that Puerto Rico cannot pursue charges against people for the same crime that federal authorities have already prosecuted them, dealing a blow to the U.S. territory’s claim that while it is not a state it should be treated like one.

Advertisement

The court ruled 6-2 in favor of defendants Luis Sanchez Valle and Jaime Gomez Vazquez, who were charged with illegally selling guns in 2008 by Puerto Rican authorities as well as federal prosecutors.

The two pleaded guilty to the federal charges and then argued that Puerto Rico’s indictments should be dismissed because of the double jeopardy clause of the U.S. Constitution that bars people from being prosecuted twice for the same offense.

A trial judge dismissed the Puerto Rico charges, but they were reinstated by an appeals court. In a March 2015 ruling, the Puerto Rico Supreme Court ruled against prosecutors, prompting the territory to appeal to the high court.

On its surface, the case was about criminal law. But it also raised questions about the extent to which the Caribbean island, which has been a U.S. territory since 1898, has sovereign powers akin to any of the 50 U.S. states. The double jeopardy clause allows U.S. states and the federal government to prosecute people separately for the same actions because they are separate sovereign entities.

The Supreme Court, in a ruling authored by Justice Elena Kagan, said that the original source of power for Puerto Rico’s Constitution came from the U.S. Congress, via a 1950 law.

“Put simply, Congress conferred the authority to create the Puerto Rico Constitution, which in turn confers the authority to bring criminal charges,” Kagan wrote.

Liberal justices Sonia Sotomayor, whose parents were from Puerto Rico, and Stephen Breyer dissented.

Some experts saw the federal government’s argument against treating Puerto Rico as a separate governmental entity as having implications for another issue: how to deal with the territory’s debt crisis.

In such a scenario, that argument could help establish a legal precedent that Puerto Rico is not a sovereign entity, possibly to justify imposing a federal control board or some other mechanism to address Puerto Rico’s roughly $70 billion in debt. The U.S. Congress is currently considering legislation on the issue.

The Supreme Court is expected to rule by the end of the month in another case involving Puerto Rico’s bid to revive a law that would allow it to cut billions of dollars in debt at public utilities in a key test in its quest to weather its crisis.

(Additional reporting by Nick Brown in San Juan)

tagreuters.com2016binary_LYNXNPEC5814I-VIEWIMAGE

Advertisement - Continue reading below

Oil price rout slams Houston’s commercial real estate market
News
Reuters 2 min read

Oil price rout slams Houston’s commercial real estate market

One of New York City’s busiest subway lines to shut for 18 months
News
Reuters 2 min read

One of New York City’s busiest subway lines to shut for 18 months

Chris Brown arrested for suspected assault at L.A. home
Entertainment
Reuters 2 min read

Chris Brown arrested for suspected assault at L.A. home

Chicago teachers sidestep strike date, tout $502 million funding plan
News
Reuters 2 min read

Chicago teachers sidestep strike date, tout $502 million funding plan

New York mayor strives to stay the course as probe queries persist
News
Reuters 3 min read

New York mayor strives to stay the course as probe queries persist

Supreme Court again rejects Illinois ex-governor’s corruption appeal
News
Reuters 1 min read

Supreme Court again rejects Illinois ex-governor’s corruption appeal

This Cave Near Portland Will Leave You Speechless
Trending
David Clarke 3 min read

This Cave Near Portland Will Leave You Speechless

Selena Gomez to take career break after panic attacks
Entertainment
Reuters 2 min read

Selena Gomez to take career break after panic attacks

Volkswagen believes it can fix 85,000 polluting U.S. vehicles
News
Reuters 2 min read

Volkswagen believes it can fix 85,000 polluting U.S. vehicles

Twitter cracks down after ‘Ghostbusters’ actor complains about abuse
Entertainment
Reuters 3 min read

Twitter cracks down after ‘Ghostbusters’ actor complains about abuse

load more Loading posts...

sidebar

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

sidebar-alt

  • About Us
  • Imprint
  • Contact Us
  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Policy